by Dirk De Vos on March 18, 2014 in Environment, News
With South Africa’s dirty record in electrical power generation it’s hard to imagine a worse place to try and tackle the environmental problems associated with it.
© Chris Marais
Eskom, which is responsible for the generation of almost all our electricity, has a terrible environmental record. Even if one ignores the environmental impact of coal mining or air pollution, at 0.96kg of CO₂ per kWh fed into the grid, Eskom is one of the world’s worst emitters of CO₂. South Africa’s economy is unusually carbon intense. Even if one discounts the problem of greenhouse gas emissions, Eskom’s power stations consume about 1 433 litres of water per MWh fed into the grid. Several studies show that 98% of South Africa’s available water resources are already allocated for other uses and there is no prospect of increasing our water supply for power generation. The water to be used by Medupi power station in the Waterberg has to be piped there from elsewhere.
We have all got used to cheap and abundant electricity and our industrial base exists because of it. But, as we have seen, things are changing quickly. We have seen exponential increases in the costs of electricity and our supply is no longer reliable as Eskom stumbles from one problem to the next with rolling blackouts now commonplace.
One of the important changes that has taken place elsewhere is the emergence of natural gas as an alternative source to coal. Coal is effectively 100% carbon. Burning one tonne of coal produces 3.7 tonnes of CO2. Natural gas (methane) or CH4 generates more heat from combustion so you only need 0.69 tonnes of methane for each tonne of coal. The CO2 from that 0.69 tonnes will only be 1.89 tonnes or half the amount of CO2 emissions. The increased use of gas is acknowledged both in the most recent edition electricity Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) and the National Development Plan.
For this reason, while natural gas is still a fossil fuel some environmentalists give it a qualified welcome. The USA has been able to increase its electricity generating output and reduce its CO2 emissions via substituting coal for gas. If China or India did the same, big inroads could be made into global carbon emissions. Gas can serve as a type of intermediary to a lower carbon world. Smart grids and better local storage/batteries are just around the corner. Once this happens, electricity could conceivably displace oil in the transport sector as well. Transport is responsible for 20% of global CO2 emissions. Better storage (in the batteries of electric vehicles) then paves the way for renewables no longer constrained by their intermittent nature.
The gas revolution is well underway and a big part of this is because of the discovery of shale gas in the USA, as well as new techniques to extract this gas via what is called hydraulic fracturing or fracking. The USA is not only becoming energy independent but has also been able to provide its citizens and businesses with cheap electricity. The debate about the environmental damage caused by fracking rages on in the USA and the impact of cheap and abundant energy reverberates around the world. Hardly a month goes by without some new claim of shale gas discovery in some part of the world.
The water scarce Karoo basin was one of those discoveries. Four years ago the US Energy Information Agency estimated that the Karoo basin holds as much as 450 trillion cubic foot (tcf) of shale gas. Many environmentalists were aghast and quickly pointed to various dangers, notably the potential contamination of ancient reservoirs of underground water. Several activist groups formed to oppose fracking in the Karoo and to target exploration companies, like Shell, who sought exploration rights. In 2012 the Minister of Mineral and Energy decided to lift the moratorium on shale gas exploration in the Karoo and followed up late last year with draft regulations governing further exploration and fracking.
© Chris Marais
The debates around fracking, its merits and dangers have filled hundreds of column inches but it has obscured the real issues. The Karoo gas will remain locked in its tight shale formations untouched for our lifetimes and those of our children. Here is why:
Most of the USA’s shale gas has been found in a shale formation known as the Marcellus Shale which at its maximum depth is 2km underground. The Karoo shale is much, much deeper at around 4km. This is not an impossible hurdle but it makes extraction much more difficult and expensive. The USA has also used natural gas for a long time and has a well developed downstream infrastructure including a vast network of pipelines which can convey the gas to the parts of the country where it can be used. We have none of these things so we will need to literally build everything from the ground up.
This then means that the floor price we will need to pay for Karoo gas will be higher than it is in the USA – to factor in the higher costs. Last month the estimates for Karoo Shale gas were revised down from 450 to 40 tcf – an order of magnitude far smaller than the initial estimate and less than Shell said was commercially exploitable.
And so the prospect of Karoo shale gas becoming an economically viable resource is poor. In part, because our neighbour Mozambique has proven conventional natural gas reserves of 100 trillion cubic feet (tcf) and its northern neighbour, Tanzania, another 30 trillion cubic feet. This is just the start: a recent study by the US Geological Survey predicts that the region has 440 Tcf of natural gas.
From: Natural Gas Master Plan for Mozambique 26 August 2012 http://www.mirem.gov.mz/relatorios/draf ... -26-12.pdf
All this will upend South Africa’s plans in the Karoo. Because Mozambique’s economy is so under-developed, it cannot consume any significant part of the resource domestically. South Africa is an obvious market for Mozambique’s gas. Already Sasol imports 450 mcf (thousand cubic feet) annually to its Secunda plant via a gas pipeline and this is due to be upgraded and expanded. Sasol has committed R33 billion to its current and future investments in Mozambique.
Developments elsewhere in the world have seen massive investments in Liquefied Natural Gas (LPG) which will see gas being transported in much the same way that oil is now – delivered to the major industrial ports and harbours of the world. This will mean that differences in gas prices (Japan pays three times the price for gas than is paid in USA) will reduce and they will reduce to below the price that we can extract Karoo gas and get it to where it can be used. For better or worse the world looks to be moving into an era of cheap gas and this does not bode well for those wanting to exploit hard to extract resources in out of the way places.
Any remaining doubts about just how dim the prospects for Karoo gas are were further dispelled last week with the passing by parliament of the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act Amendment Bill which included a raft of regulations that empowered the Minister of Mineral Resources to take key decisions but also alows the State to have a free 20% stake in all exploration and production rights and the rights to buy the remainder of shares at “an agreed price”. It is an ill-advised piece of legislation that will stymie any investment in mining or gas. It takes the prospect of Karoo shale gas off the table.
© Christian Boix
Approximate Conversion Factors
The metrics used in the Gas Market differ from oil prices. The metric measurement used for gas is gigajoules (GJ). In the US, the measurement used is Million British Thermal Units (MMBtu). These measurements are roughly equivalent ( 1 GJ = 0.95 MMBtu)
There are roughly 35,31 trillion cubic feet (Tcf) in 1 cubic meter (TCM) of gas
A barrel of oil (bbl) equals 42 gallons or nearly 160litres of oil.
1 tonne of LNG equals 52MMBTU
There is approximately 6 MmBtu or 6 GJ of natural gas in a barrel of oil equivalent
A barrel of oil (bbl) is 42 gallons or 160 litres of oil.
A barrel of oil renders approximately 1.7MWh.
1 tonne of LNG renders approximately 15.2MWh
1 tonne of LNG equals 9 bbl of crude oil
1 mtpa of LNG equals 130MMBTU/day or 1.37 Billion cubic metres (Bcm)
Current Combined cycle gas power plant use roughly 7 000 MmBtu to produce 1GWh of electricity.
1mpta of LNG is sufficient to supply a 1 GW Combined Cycle Gas Plan running at a load factor of 90%
Mozambique generated 16 963 GWh of electricity in 2009 (World Bank)
Eskom has a total generating capacity of roughly 38 000 MW of which more than 90% is from coal fired power stations and consumes over 90 million tons of coal per annum to generate about 196 308GWh of electricity per annum.
Theoretically, If SA replaced all its coal fired power stations with combined cycle gas stations, it would consume nearly 1.4tcf of natural gas per year.
Why Fracking in the Karoo will never happen
Information and Discussions on Mining Issues
- Lisbeth
- Site Admin
- Posts: 67237
- Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
- Country: Switzerland
- Location: Lugano
- Contact:
Why Fracking in the Karoo will never happen
"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
Return to “Mining and Other Extraction Issues”
Jump to
- Africa Wild Board Information
- ↳ Forum Information
- ↳ Africa Wild Forum Information
- ↳ Benefits for Africa Wild Members
- ↳ Questions
- ↳ Suggestions
- Conservation and Management Issues of Concern
- ↳ Rhino Management and Poaching
- ↳ Elephant Management and Poaching
- ↳ General Poaching
- ↳ Developments and Commercialisation in National Parks
- ↳ Proposed Developments in National Parks
- ↳ General Hotel Discussions, KNP
- ↳ Proposed Skukuza Hotel, KNP
- ↳ Proposed Re-zoning, KNP
- ↳ Proposed Developments, KNP
- ↳ Proposed Developments, KTP
- ↳ Sporting (and other events) in National Parks
- ↳ SANParks' Management Issues
- ↳ General Management Issues - SANParks
- ↳ General Management Issues - Kruger
- ↳ Fire Experiments & Fire Management in KNP
- ↳ Vehicle Accidents in Kruger
- ↳ River Systems & Waterhole Management in KNP
- ↳ General Management Issues - Other National Parks
- ↳ SANParks' Gallery of Shame
- ↳ Ezemvelo KZN Management Issues
- ↳ General Conservation Issues
- ↳ Endangered Species
- ↳ Endangered Ecosystems
- ↳ Hunting
- ↳ Mining and Other Extraction Issues
- ↳ Other Conservation Issues
- ↳ Global Climate Change
- ↳ In the News
- ↳ Park Facilities: Needs Attention
- ↳ Lions and Other Endangered Animals Management and Poaching
- Public Participation - Kruger Management Plan
- ↳ Public Participation - Kruger Management Plan
- Africa Wild Campaigns
- ↳ Africa Wild Causes
- ↳ Petitions Forum
- ↳ World Rhino Day
- ↳ Support Anti Rhino Poaching
- Africa Wild Directory to Game Parks of Southern Africa
- ↳ All you need to know about Game and Bird Spotting
- ↳ All you need to know about South African National Parks
- ↳ South African National Parks in General
- ↳ Kruger National Park
- ↳ Kruger Information & General Discussion Forum
- ↳ Congestion in Kruger
- ↳ Camps of Kruger
- ↳ Favourite Routes in Kruger
- ↳ Gates, Hides, Lookouts & Picnic Spots in Kruger
- ↳ Wilderness and 4x4 Trails
- ↳ Travelling to and from Kruger
- ↳ Fauna and Flora of Kruger Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of Kruger
- ↳ History of Kruger
- ↳ Awards Survey
- ↳ Addo Elephant National Park
- ↳ Kgalagadi Transfrontier Park
- ↳ KTP Information and General Discussion Forum
- ↳ Camps of KTP
- ↳ Pics of Creatures Spotted in KTP
- ↳ Travel Tales of KTP
- ↳ Mapungubwe National Park
- ↳ Agulhas National Park
- ↳ Augrabies Falls National Park
- ↳ Namaqua National Park
- ↳ Bontebok National Park
- ↳ Karoo National Park
- ↳ Golden Gate Highlands National Park
- ↳ Camdeboo National Park
- ↳ Garden Route National Park
- ↳ Marakele National Park
- ↳ Mokala National Park
- ↳ Mountain Zebra National Park
- ↳ Table Mountain National Park
- ↳ Tankwa Karoo National Park
- ↳ West Coast National Park
- ↳ Ai-Ais Richtersveld Transfrontier Park
- ↳ All you need to know about Kwa Zulu Natal Game Parks
- ↳ Hluhluwe/Imfolozi Game Reserve
- ↳ Mkuze Game Reserve
- ↳ Ndumo Game Reserve
- ↳ Ithala Game Reserve
- ↳ iSimangaliso Wetland Park
- ↳ Tembe Elephant Park
- ↳ Other KZN Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Travel tales of KZN Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about other South African Game Parks
- ↳ Pilanesberg Game Reserve
- ↳ Gauteng Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ North West Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Limpopo Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Western Cape Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Northern Cape Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Eastern Cape Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Free State Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Mpumalanga Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ All you need to know about Botswana Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Mozambique Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Namibia Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Eswatini (Swaziland) Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Tanzania Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Zambia Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Malawi Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Zimbabwe Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Kenya Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Uganda Game Parks
- ↳ Questions and discussions on all Southern African Parks
- Africa Wild Travel Tales
- ↳ Africa Wild Travel Tales
- ↳ Travel Tales of South African National Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Kruger National Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of Kgalagadi Transfrontier National Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of Addo Elephant National Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of Mapungubwe National Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of other South African National Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of KZN Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Hluhluwe/Imfolozi Game Reserve
- ↳ Travel Tales of Ndumo Game Reserve
- ↳ Travel Tales of Mkuze Game Reserve
- ↳ Travel Tales of Ithala Game Reserve
- ↳ Travel Tales of Tembe Elephant Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of Other KZN Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Other South African Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Pilanesberg Game Reserve
- ↳ Travel Tales of North West Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Limpopo Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Eastern Cape Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Western Cape Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Northern Cape Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Gauteng Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Free State Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Mpumalanga Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Botswana Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Namibia Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Zimbabwe Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Tanzania Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Central & East Africa Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Swaziland Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Zambia Parks
- ↳ Tales of Wildlife Experiences & Animal Behaviour
- ↳ Travel Tales of Africa Wild Adventures
- ↳ Travel Tales from around the World
- African Wildlife: Animals, Birds, Plants
- ↳ Mammals
- ↳ Birds
- ↳ Reptiles
- ↳ Amphibians and Fishes
- ↳ Invertebrates
- ↳ Plants
- ↳ The Monthly How, What & Why of Wildlife
- Africa Wild Special Interests
- ↳ Africa Wild Photography
- ↳ Pic of the Day
- ↳ Pic of the Month 2024
- ↳ Pic of the Month 2022/2023
- ↳ Pic of the Year 2023
- ↳ Pic of the Year 2022
- ↳ Pic of the Year 2021
- ↳ Archived Galleries 2011-2024
- ↳ Gallery the Year 2011
- ↳ Bird Pic of the Year 2011
- ↳ Animal Pic of the Year 2011
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2012
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2014
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2015
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2013
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2016
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2017
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2018
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2019
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2020
- ↳ Gallery of the year 2021
- ↳ Gallery of the year 2022
- ↳ Gallery of the year 2023
- ↳ General Photography Discussion Forum
- ↳ Technical Photography Discussion Forum
- ↳ Photo Competition - Your Best Photo of.....
- ↳ Webcams
- ↳ Monthly Webcam Gallery
- ↳ Webcam Sightings
- ↳ Africa Wild Quizzies & Games
- ↳ Wildlife from Out of Africa
- ↳ The Fishing Hole
- ↳ Books & Recommended Reading
- ↳ Heritage
- ↳ Natural World
- ↳ Environmental Activists
- Africa Wild Travel and Holiday Information
- ↳ Your Holidays - Responsible Tourism
- ↳ Dongas & Dust
- ↳ Camping
- ↳ Travel Advice and Discussions
- Africa Wild Social Forum
- ↳ The Rhino Midden