Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Information and Discussions on General Conservation Issues
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67587
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Post by Lisbeth »

Image
The Sea Search Research and Conservation team has been keeping track of hundreds of dead Cape fur seals that have washed up in areas along the West Coast of South Africa. (Photo: Sea Search Research and Conservation)

By Tembile Sgqolana | 25 Oct 2021

Seal mortalities are not uncommon at this time of the year, but the rapid increase in numbers has alarmed the Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Marine scientists are trying to find out why hundreds of malnourished and dead Cape fur seals have washed up on to the West Coast of South Africa.

The Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE) sent its technicians and scientists, specifically dedicated to seals, to do an inspection visit at the onset of the mortalities in September.

DFFE spokesperson Zolile Nqayi said that in September St Helena Bay had seven mortalities and Elands Bay had nine.

“Four of the encountered carcasses were sampled for veterinary tests. Preliminary observations from the DFFE team were that carcasses had signs of undernourishment/malnutrition,” he said.

Nqayi said the mortalities had since increased and coincided with an outbreak of avian flu in the same areas.

“Although seal mortalities are not uncommon at this time of the year, the rapid increase in numbers has alarmed the department and its stakeholders. The department has since approached the state veterinarian at the Western Cape’s Department of Agriculture for assistance with postmortems,” he said.

“Due to the scale of this event, the department is monitoring the situation in cooperation with other conservation management agencies, NGOs, academic institutions and private citizens,” he said.

He said at this time of year there is an increase in natural seal mortalities due to mothers weaning pups of the previous breeding cycle (in this case 2020), in preparation for the next breeding season (October-December).

“In some instances, weaned pups are not strong enough to feed by themselves and will not survive. A similar phenomenon was reported off the Namibian coast in 2020. Officials have also noted from reports that there are cases that involve older animals. These also seem malnourished and convulsions were noted from at least two of the videos shared with the department,” Nqayi said.

He said it is clear that these seals are starving to death.

“Current indications are that mortalities are limited to the West Coast (Lambert’s Bay, Elands Bay, St Helena Bay and Paternoster). The state veterinarian has prioritised testing for avian flu as carcasses are submitted. The department will issue an update upon completion of initial postmortems,” said Nqayi.

Sea Search and Namibian Dolphin Project co-director Dr Tess Gridley last week said many seals were emaciated and more had died.

“We don’t know why, and all we can do is document the dead and dying.”

Image
Cape fur seals have washed up dead in areas along the West Coast, including Lambert’s Bay, Elands Bay, St Helena Bay and Paternoster. (Photo: Sea Search Research and Conservation)

Image
A dead Cape fur seal on South Africa’s West Coast. (Photo: Sea Search Research and Conservation)

Earlier warning signs

Gridley said they were alerted by several reports of higher than normal mortalities of Cape fur seals at Paternoster, Shelley Beach and Elands Bay around September 11-12.

“On September 21 to 23, we found 17 carcasses along a 2km section of Shelley Beach… [At] Lamberts Bay the next day we observed greater mortalities of new born-preterm pups, juvenile and sub-adults. More than 100 dead animals were found around the periphery of the colony; females were birthing pups almost two months early and they did not make it,” she said.

Gridley said at Elands Bay, a smaller colony, they counted 158 dead seals in an hour with distressing scenes of aborted foetuses and emaciated seals.

“Whilst Cape fur seal populations are well known to boom or bust, die-offs are not uncommon. Documenting such events and investigating the cause is worthwhile… such events could indicate the underlying health of the marine ecosystem. In addition to the unhealthy seals, we noted several sick and dying seabirds as well as multiple seal entanglements in fishing lines,” Gridley said.

She said they are feeding data to those responsible for marine resources in South Africa, and working with the marine mammal community to gain a better picture on what is happening at these seal colonies.

Gridley said this time of year for Cape fur seals is a time of high energy demand and some naturally don’t make it.

“Yearlings are now forced to fully wean, and females are heavily pregnant, with pupping due to start in earnest in mid-November. Combined with strong south-easterly winds, we often see high numbers of dead youngsters on our beaches,” she said.

Image
The Sea Search Research and Conservation team inspects the crisis on the West Coast. (Photo: Sea Search Research and Conservation)

Image
The Sea Search Research and Conservation team is investigating the dead Cape fur seals on the West Coast. (Photo: Sea Search Research and Conservation)

In Hout Bay

Hout Bay Seal Rescue Centre’s Kim Krynauw said huge numbers of young seals are coming on to the shore.

“They are basically dying of starvation due to overfishing. We have rescued over 25 yearlings in the past few weeks and it is sad as many are washing up dead all over the coast,” she said.

Krynauw said their team is also on the ground helping to collect data.

Strandloper Project manager Mark Dixon said the dead seals are a concern and this is occurring along the coastline from Knysna to Hout Bay.

“On our recent expedition we recorded numerous dead seals and plenty of yearlings; this and a few other things do suggest that there is a shortage of food in the ocean, not only for the seals but for other species as well.” DM/OBP


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Richprins
Committee Member
Posts: 76114
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 3:52 pm
Location: NELSPRUIT
Contact:

Re: Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Post by Richprins »

:shock: O-/


Please check Needs Attention pre-booking: https://africawild-forum.com/viewtopic.php?f=322&t=596
User avatar
Mel
Global Moderator
Posts: 28269
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Germany
Location: Föhr
Contact:

Re: Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Post by Mel »

And with them the whales, sharks and dolphins will diminish. :-(


God put me on earth to accomplish a certain amount of things. Right now I'm so far behind that I'll never die.
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67587
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Post by Lisbeth »

As hundreds of seals buried Western Cape government awaits report on cause of deaths

09.11.21 - accreditation Nicole McCain -

Image

The results of a Western Cape government investigation into an, "... alarming spike in seal deaths", along the province's coast is expected this week.

Local Government, Environmental Affairs and Development Planning MEC Anton Bredell said the State Veterinary service is expected to issue a report, following tests on the dead seals.

The province has seen an increase in seal deaths, with nearly 200 seals buried in one day. Experts have speculated that the deaths could be as a result of malnutrition, but they have ruled out any connection with an avian flu outbreak in the province.

Conservation group Sea Search estimates that thousands of Cape fur seals have died.

Bredell said his department is aware of the dying seals that have been washing up along the coast.

"The experts say that some deaths amongst seal populations at this time of the year can be expected. However, what we are seeing is an abnormally high number of animals sick and dying on the coastline. We are committed to finding out why and the State Veterinary service is already conducting tests on dead seals to determine the cause of these deaths. This report is expected this week."

Several partners and NGOs are, "... working tirelessly on the problem", said Bredell. Among them is the Sea Search Team, whom the public is urged to contact on seasearchseals@gmail.com if they find a dead seal along the shoreline.

"Please send a picture, location and date. The Sea Search team is collating records to further their understanding on the current die off," Bredell adds.

UPDATE ON SEAL MORTALITY EVENT IN WESTERN CAPE
I was asked for an update. I could give you the facts but there is SO much we don't know (yet)...
I do know this much though...
On Friday I awoke to reports of a yearling seal dying between Muizenberg and St James, and another very thin animal at the St James pool. I packed my kids off to school and stopped to find the animals on the drive home.
Watching as the youngster convulsed I phoned Vet Brett Gardner in Australia - who at the end of a long shift, advised me what to look out for as the animal died in front of my eyes. Members of the public passed on by, thinking the seal was asleep, thinking it might bite their dogs - but no, this was one of hundreds of animals which have died over the weekend. I left the animal, and found the second skinny youngster at St James - weak and emaciated. Leaving it to rest I spoke to passing members of the public asking them to report seals along the coastline if they see them, so we can collate data on the current die off. I check my phone - an adult female is convulsing at Witsand (Kommetjie), moments from death phoned in by a fisherman who clearly cared for the animal- what should and could we do... Another in Melkbossstrand is being put to sleep by the SPCA - the body not available for science and therefore lost without valuable information collected.
Its 10 am... The coffee hasn't even kicked in properly... requests from media, government and scientists for information. We have not got a clear picture what's going on, but it's worrying.
Every time I check my phone or email there are more records coming in...
This is a taster of the past 72 hrs... there's much more to write to this story.
We are doing what we can but it is not enough to really understand the cause of the seal die off currently. We need to do more pathology testing at the vet lab which is pricey, we need to travel north to see what's happening there and we need more time to collate all the records sent to us by valuable and concerned members of the public - the true citizen scientists.
The government departments apparently have no budget for further testing - if you can support this work - please see the funding links in pinned post above. www.seasearch.co.za/support
A huge thanks to all involved who are helping send in sightings, collect animals and coordinate sampling.
We are living seals right now - as they are dying.
Tess
Hout Bay Seal Rescue Centre SANCCOB saves seabirds The owl orphanage. #rescue #science #animals #seals #capetown #westcoast


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67587
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Post by Lisbeth »

Ripple effect: The sad story of the Western Cape ‘refugee’ seals

Image
Dead or dying Cape fur seals have washed up along South Africa’s coast since October.

By Caryn Dolley | 22 Nov 2021

Malnourished Cape fur seals, probably from the Western Cape, are washing up along South Africa’s Eastern Cape coast.
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Scores of dead or dying Cape fur seals have been washing up along South Africa’s West Coast since October. Now researchers suspect that seals from that area are starting to wash up along the Eastern Cape coast while searching for food.

Marine researchers in the Eastern Cape suspect the seal die-off happening along the West Coast of South Africa, which has involved hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals and carcasses washing up, is starting to have a ripple effect.


This week Greg Hofmeyr, curator of marine mammals at Bayworld in Gqeberha, told DM168 that recently more weaned seal pups than usual had started washing ashore.

The seal pups, known as underyearlings, ranged from about 10 to 12 months old.

They were thin.

Hofmeyr said it was not unusual for a few Cape fur seals to end up on the shore along the Southern and Eastern Cape at this time of the year.

But more than usual have been spotted over the past few weeks and he said it was suspected that these seals were from the West Coast areas and in search of food along the Eastern Cape coast.

Daily Maverick reported in October that seal mortalities were not unusual at this time of the year.

However, there had been an unexpected and sharp increase.

At the time, Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment spokesperson Zolile Nqayi said: “In some instances, weaned pups are not strong enough to feed by themselves and will not survive. A similar phenomenon was reported off the Namibian coast in 2020.

“Officials have also noted from reports that there are cases that involve older animals. These also seem malnourished, and convulsions were noted from at least two of the videos shared with the department.”

The reason for the sharp increase in seal deaths was being investigated.

Image
Now researchers suspect seals are starting to wash up along the Eastern Cape coast while searching for food.

In a Facebook post on Bayworld’s page this week, Hofmeyr said the seal mortality event around Cape Town was by now well known and that the seals that ended up ashore appeared very thin.

“But seals of the Southern and Eastern Cape seem to have enough to eat.

“I visited Black Rocks in Algoa Bay two weeks ago and the seals there seemed very fat and healthy, with not a single thin seal in sight,” he said.

“My colleagues Dr Gwen Penry from the Plett Stranding Network and Val Marsh from S.M.A.R.T. in Mossel Bay also indicated that the seals at their colonies look very healthy. So the seals of the Agulhas Current Ecosystem seem to be doing well.

“But despite this, since the beginning of October, we have all seen many more thin seals ashore on the mainland than normal. And these are almost all recently weaned pups and most are very thin. It is quite possible that these animals are ‘refugees’ from the Western Cape.”

Hofmeyr urged people to please report any shore seal sightings to Bayworld’s hotline on 071 724 2122.

Meanwhile, Sea Search, a group of scientists and students, this week reported that the 2021 seal mortality rate was unusual for several reasons.

This included pregnant seals aborting at a higher rate from September onwards at colonies in South Africa and Namibia, “resulting in both higher numbers of wash-out of dead black pups, and in some cases subsequent death of the adult female”.

“Adults displaying potential neurological symptoms” were also picked up, “as well as animals of all ages displaying convulsions when in final two hours or so of death (some of this is linked to death by starvation).” DM168


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67587
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Post by Lisbeth »

Over-fishing? -O-


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Richprins
Committee Member
Posts: 76114
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 3:52 pm
Location: NELSPRUIT
Contact:

Re: Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Post by Richprins »

-O-


Please check Needs Attention pre-booking: https://africawild-forum.com/viewtopic.php?f=322&t=596
User avatar
Richprins
Committee Member
Posts: 76114
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 3:52 pm
Location: NELSPRUIT
Contact:

Re: Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Post by Richprins »

Reason for Mossel Bay seal deaths uncertain
A large number of dead seals washed up in the Cape recently and more seals than usual from the West Coast to Qqeberha.
20 hours ago
Mossel Bay Advertiser

Image
A seal pup being rescued. Photo: Mossel Bay Advertiser

The Mossel Bay Advertiser contacted the Stranded Marine Animal Rescue Team (S.M.A.R.T.) to find out the situation with regards to seals washing up on beaches.

Three weeks ago, 35 seals were found dead or dying on beaches in the greater Mossel Bay area.

S.M.A.R.T. committee member and volunteer Val Marsh said it was a relief that only seven dead seals were found the week after that and then two, compared with the 35 that were found three weeks ago.

She pointed out that it could be that there were more dead seals in rocky bays that were not visited and on Seal Island in the bay, that one did not know about.

Marsh said the seals were under yearlings. They were much thinner than normal and smaller for their age. This was not a black seal pup wash-up phenomenon, Marsh said. (Each year seal pups wash up because of bad weather.)
Carcasses

She said people should not be impatient about the carcasses not being removed quickly enough. She thanked the municipality that it had appointed outside contractors to remove the carcasses and she said these contractors had worked extremely hard and as fast as possible to remove the carcasses.

A large number of dead seals washed up in the Cape recently and more seals than usual from the West Coast to Qqeberha. Respected South African marine scientist Tess Gridley, based in the Cape, said she was still awaiting necropsy reports from the State. She had been waiting for five weeks.

Gqeberha-based marine scientist Greg Hofmeyr said the dead seals washing up in Queberha were extremely thin and it was thought they had come from the Cape. He said the animals were young and recently weaned, almost a year old.

He said the animals at Seal Island, Robberg in Plettenberg Bay and in Algoa Bay were fatter and in better condition, therefore he believed the dead seals washing up had come from the Cape and were not local animals. “This is just one line of thinking,” he said.

Hofmeyr said he had visited the colonies from Mossel Bay to Gqeberha and the “animals are in very good condition”.
All ages

He said the deaths of seals in the Cape were of animals of all ages.

He said the seals washing up from Mossel Bay to Gqeberha looked as if they were starving, with no obvious signs of any other condition.

“It seems to me these are starving animals that are moving eastwards from around Cape Town and it seems they are younger animals that are more inclined to travel further afield, especially recently weaned pups.”

Hofmeyr said it was vitally important that members of the public continued to report stranded seals to S.M.A.R.T. (072 227 4715) so that statistics and data could be compiled.

https://lowvelder.co.za/lnn/1161057/rea ... knCsLXvZkc


Please check Needs Attention pre-booking: https://africawild-forum.com/viewtopic.php?f=322&t=596
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67587
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Post by Lisbeth »

Nothing new.


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Richprins
Committee Member
Posts: 76114
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 3:52 pm
Location: NELSPRUIT
Contact:

Re: Hundreds of malnourished Cape fur seals wash up dead on South Africa’s shores

Post by Richprins »

Experts still baffled by South African seal die-off

22 December 2021 - 17:11
Bobby Jordan Senior reporter



Marine experts are concerned about the condition of Cape fur seals as carcasses continue to wash up along the SA coast.

Government is yet to determine the cause of the widespread seal die-off that extends from at least Lambert's Bay on the West Coast to Hermanus in the southern Cape.

Several thousand animals have died over the past three months, though the exact number is unclear and organisations are pulling together to collect valuable information. The deaths coincide with a normal annual spike in pup and yearling deaths linked to the seal breeding cycle, but this year the mortality rate is much higher and includes many sub-adult and adult seals. The start of the die-off also coincided with an avian flu outbreak that killed thousands of seabirds.

Though government remains tight-lipped about its seal post-mortem results, some experts have urged the public to report seal deaths and to be cautious about handling carcasses, particularly during the holiday period with more people at the coast. Initial lab tests, as yet unconfirmed, suggest the deaths could be similar to other historic die-offs that have been linked to toxic sea life, similar to that which affects shellfish during “red tide”.

“My opinion is that this appears to be a pathogen/toxin, in conjunction with some animals being malnourished,” said veterinarian Brett Gardner, who has researched seal infections in Australia and Namibia.

“The typical lesions are in the lungs and brain, so together with the seizures it narrows the list of causes down,” Gardner said, adding that there were multiple pathogens that could cause mass mortality, all of which needed to be investigated.

Stellenbosch University marine scientist Dr Tess Gridley said the delay in a formal diagnosis was due to the detailed and difficult analysis required, involving post mortems on only the freshest animals and brain sample analysis.

“It is not just a case of looking at the animal ... Really detailed investigation is required,” Gridley said. “As this is also the breeding time, access to the colonies is restricted, making it difficult to assess the situation more thoroughly in the busiest seal areas.”

As soon as I started walking along the beach my insides turned upside down. Apart from the immeasurable amount of rubbish just everywhere (and this is a National Park), I was greeted by a sight I was not prepared for – hundreds of dead seals strewn along a very long stretch of beach.

Social media post

She urged the public not to approach sick seals or seemingly abandoned pups, but rather to report these to the SPCA or Hout Bay Seal Rescue Centre.

In November the Western Cape government also urged the public to stay away from dead seals.

“The testing is taking a while longer than previously expected,” the provincial environmental affairs department said.

Reports of dead seals continued this week, including from the West Coast National Park, where hundreds of carcasses washed up on well-known 16 Mile Beach.

“Today I came across one of the most devastating sights I have ever seen,” said one post on the Community Clean-Up Initiative WhatsApp group.

“As soon as I started walking along the beach my insides turned upside down. Apart from the immeasurable amount of rubbish just everywhere (and this is a National Park), I was greeted by a sight I was not prepared for — hundreds of dead seals strewn along a very long stretch of beach.”

Similar scenes have been reported from other coastal areas over the past few months.

Gregg Oelofse, Cape Town's marine manager, said the city was assisting with carcass counting.

Fortunately there is also some good news for ocean enthusiasts: white sharks have been spotted in False Bay, after a lengthy absence from one of their historic hunting grounds.

The Shark Spotters Safety Education Research Conservation in Cape Town issued a warning earlier this month after four great white and bronze whaler sharks were spotted off Cape beaches. Pictures of great whites visiting ski boats have also circulated on social media, prompting numerous comments.

“This is good news for our marine ecosystem,” said Liza Weschta.

“It would be wonderful to witness their return,” agreed Sue Rosenberg.

However, a few sightings should not obscure the bigger picture of a steady decline in SA’s white shark population, possibly due to anthropogenic activities, according to Dr Sara Andreotti, a marine biologist affiliated to Stellenbosch University’s Department of Botany and Zoology.

“The population decline and the potential crash of white sharks in South Africa don't mean that we won't still have sporadic sightings of a few individuals,” Andreotti said.

TimesLIVE

https://www.sowetanlive.co.za/news/sout ... l-die-off/


Please check Needs Attention pre-booking: https://africawild-forum.com/viewtopic.php?f=322&t=596
Post Reply

Return to “Other Conservation Issues”