Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67571
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Post by Lisbeth »

Image
Cheetah mothers are attentive and hide newborn cubs in tall grass or move their den sites regularly. They generally give birth to a litter of four cubs. (Photo: Rosie Miles)

By Tony Carnie | 09 Aug 2022

Fifteen cheetahs — 12 from South Africa and three from Namibia — are about to embark on a 9,000km journey to India, where the government hopes to restore that country’s extinct population of the charismatic species.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Cheetahs were a widespread and intrinsic feature of India for millennia. The very name of this animal originates from the Sanskrit word chita/chitraka, meaning “the spotted one”.

Prized by the nobility because of their speed, cheetahs were frequently used for coursing (hunting down other animals such as antelope) but were also later shot for sport by hunters. The Mughal emperor Akbar is reputed to have kept 1,000 cheetahs in his menagerie, collecting as many as 9,000 during his 49-year reign in the 16th century.

Image
A painting of Shah Jehan using trained cheetahs to hunt blackbuck in Rajasthan in the early 1600s. (Image: The Met Museum, New York)

But the inability to breed them in captivity meant that cheetahs (and cubs) had to be constantly trapped in the wild to keep the sport alive over centuries. By the time the British arrived in India, the spotted ones were making their last stand and had vanished from the landscape almost entirely by the early 1950s.

That’s about to change.

Image
Some of the last cheetahs in India were shot in 1947, though wildlife historian and scholar Divyabhanusinh reports credible sightings of isolated cheetahs in remote areas into the 1960s and possibly 1975. (Photo: Constant Hoogstad)

Coinciding with India’s 76th Independence Day celebration on 15 August, 15 southern African cheetahs are due to touch down in New Delhi shortly before the official festivities. They will then be taken to their new home range in the Kuno National Park in Madhya Pradesh state, bringing to fruition a long-held ambition by several Indian wildlife officials to bring cheetahs back from extinction.

Well, almost…

Though visually identical, the southern African cheetah (Acinonyx jubatus jubatus) is slightly different from the Asiatic cheetah subspecies (A. j. venaticus), having been separated genetically for several thousand years.

Image
Cheetahs have vanished from 90% of their historical range in Africa and almost entirely the Middle East/Asia. The grey shading shows their historical range, and the red shading shows the range where cheetah are believed to be resident. (Source: PNAS / Durant et al 2016)

India has been trying to source Asiatic specimens since the mid-1950s. During the 1970s, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi was on the brink of reaching an agreement to swap Indian lions for Iranian cheetahs when the Shah of Iran was swept from power. The deal collapsed.

At the time, Iran still had about 400 wild cheetahs. Now there are fewer than 30 critically endangered Asiatic cheetahs left in the world (all in Iran) and this wild population is too small to be fragmented for relocation to other nations.

But the dream of bringing cheetahs back was revived in 2009 by the Wildlife Trust of India, culminating in a decision by the Supreme Court of India in 2020 to sanction the acquisition of cheetahs from southern Africa. The court ruled that a committee of experts should take a careful decision about the viability of introducing these animals to the Kuno National Park first, followed by a larger-scale introduction to other large Indian wildlife reserves.

This is where southern Africa fits in.

Should the experiment take root, up to 75 cheetahs could be shifted to India over the next 10 years.

Image
A cheetah in Welgevonden Game Reserve in Limpopo. Somewhere between 60% and 80% of cheetah kittens die before reaching adulthood. Most are killed by lions, hyenas and leopards. (Photo: Mark Matheson)

Namibia, Botswana, South Africa and Zimbabwe conserve the largest remaining populations of wild cheetahs in the world — down to just 7,000 globally.

To boost these precarious numbers, the Johannesburg-based Endangered Wildlife Trust initiated the Cheetah Metapopulation Project in 2011 to shift and swap wild cheetahs between relatively small but securely fenced wildlife reserves.

Led by Vincent van der Merwe, the project has proved a remarkable success, more than doubling this metapopulation from 217 to 504 cheetahs in less than a decade. The animals are now spread across 69 reserves in four countries.

Relocations

In 2017, Van der Merwe coordinated the first reintroductions into Malawi, followed by further moves to Zambia and Mozambique. Now, should everything go to plan, 15 cheetahs will be heading to India shortly to test whether they can adapt to very similar conditions in India.

Image
Vincent van der Merwe (right) and wildlife vet Dr Brendan Tindall oversee the translocation of another two cheetahs from a South African reserve. (Photo: Cynthia Stroo)

“There are no major differences between the savannas of Africa and India, and (apart from dense forest, extreme mountains and desert) our metapopulation cheetahs persist in a wide variety of biomes including semi-desert, thicket, sand forest, savanna and grassland.”

As coordinator of the metapopulation, his job was to identify a suitable founder population — young, ecologically functional and predator-savvy cheetahs.

In southern Africa, a crucial factor for successful cheetah relocations has been securely fenced reserves, frequent animal swaps to avoid inbreeding and the sound management of other predator densities such as lions and leopards that often kill cheetahs and their cubs.

Image
Cheetah metapopulation coordinator Vincent van der Merwe on a recent visit to Iran. (Photo: Supplied)

“When released into Kuno National Park in India, these cheetahs will have to fend for themselves in an environment where competing predators such as leopards, wolves and sloth bears will be out to get them,” says Van der Merwe, acknowledging that there could be heavy initial losses (especially very young offspring) due to predation, starvation or snaring.

In South Africa, translocated animals are normally kept briefly in boma enclosures and supplied with fresh antelope meat shot by rangers.

In India, however, where such killing is not permitted for cultural and religious reasons, the new cheetahs will have to fend for themselves initially in 5ha bomas. Then they will be released after the monsoon season into the unfenced 75,000ha reserve, which is surrounded by a 42,000ha buffer zone.

phpBB [video]


The 12 South African cheetahs have been sourced from five protected areas — four from Tswalu Kalahari Reserve in the Northern Cape; three from andBeyond Phinda Private Game Reserve in KwaZulu-Natal, two from Welgevonden Game Reserve in Limpopo, two from the Waterberg Biosphere (Limpopo) and one from Mapesu Private Game Reserve (Limpopo).

The costs of capturing the animals and for disease testing, vaccinations, tracking devices and training of Indian wildlife officials have been paid by the National Tiger Conservation Authority of India.

Image
Locator map showing Kuno National Park where the first southern African cheetahs will go. (Photo: Supplied)

Professors Adrian Tordiffe and Leith Meyer of the University of Pretoria’s Centre for Veterinary Wildlife Studies are also playing a key role in the cheetah introduction.

Tordiffe said his role was to get the animals safely to India and prevent them from becoming infected or transmitting any disease to Indian carnivores.

He notes that the animals will not be lost to South Africa as the metapopulation project involves frequent exchange of animals to ensure effective gene flow.

Image
Chital antelope in Kuno National Park. (Photo: Supplied)

“Very few new reserves can accommodate cheetahs in South Africa, and if no new space is found to accommodate the expanding population, animals will have to be placed on contraceptives to limit their numbers. This would be a tragedy, when there are protected areas within their historical range elsewhere in the world,” he said.

Nevertheless, Van der Merwe acknowledges that there is a long journey ahead.

Image
For a hunt to be successful, cheetahs need to get as close as possible to their prey, before starting the final sprint. They will try to get within 100m of their target before embarking on a chase and mostly choose prey isolated from the rest of the herd. (Photo: A Donaldson)

“The Indian conservation authorities will learn as we go along, as we have learnt in southern Africa where more than 70 cheetah reintroductions have been attempted since 1965.

“Mistakes will be made initially, but lessons will be learnt and Indian authorities will develop capacity over time. Keep in mind that India has a good track record in large carnivore conservation, with their wild tiger population more than doubling in size since 2006. The ultimate goal will be cheetah reintroductions into their tiger reserves as these are the best-protected areas in India.” DM/OBP


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Richprins
Committee Member
Posts: 76096
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 3:52 pm
Location: NELSPRUIT
Contact:

Re: Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Post by Richprins »

\O \O \O


Please check Needs Attention pre-booking: https://africawild-forum.com/viewtopic.php?f=322&t=596
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67571
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Post by Lisbeth »

Translocation of SA cheetahs to India — ‘there is going to be a lot of heartache and pain’

Image
Three cheetah cubs with their mother. Cheetah mothers have to be extra vigilant to protect their cubs as they are easy prey both for predators from above (raptors) and on the ground (lions). (Photo: Kalyan Varma)

By Don Pinnock | 03 Oct 2022

Some say sending African cheetahs to India is a brilliant idea, others insist it’s possible but with warnings, and some say it’s an absolute disaster.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
If the 20 African cheetahs destined for Kuno National Park in India die – and there’s a good chance they will – it won’t be met with the same fanfare as their arrival.

The question we would then need to ask is whether they were sacrificed for the greater good of conservation or for a national vanity project.

The cheetahs were planned to arrive on India’s Independence Day (15 August) but didn’t make the date. Instead, they got there on 17 September in time for the birthday of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who released them into a boma in Kuno National Park.

Twelve more are about to arrive from South Africa, pending the signing of a memorandum of understanding.

Image
Cheetah and cub. (Photo: Kalyan Varma)

Some say sending African cheetahs to India is a brilliant idea, others insist it’s possible but with warnings, and some say it’s an absolute disaster. The cost is estimated at R200-million in the first five years. The Wildlife Institute of India estimates that in the first year only 50% will survive.

Is it a reasonable project? You be the judge.

The Indian government

For India, the symbolism is important. Cheetahs have been integral to Indian heritage, folklore and culture since time immemorial. The last cheetah in India was shot in the 1940s. It’s the only large wild mammal to go locally extinct. Their return is a mark of national pride.

India’s environment minister, Bhupender Yadav, tweeted: “Completing 75 glorious years of Independence with restoring the fastest terrestrial flagship species, the cheetah, in India, will rekindle the ecological dynamics of the landscape.”

Their import also flags international cooperation around rewilding, the introduction of a top predator and the rebalancing of biodiversity.

After much legal wrangling, the introduction was approved by the Supreme Court of India in 2020. It was also approved by the Namibian government and is awaiting official approval from South Africa’s Department of Forestry, Fisheries and Environment.

What could possibly go wrong?

The vet

Cheetahs aren’t the best travellers. There’s a high risk of mortality in translocation. Seven of the first eight wild cheetah reintroductions attempted within South Africa between 1966 and 1995 failed, with the cats dying after release. More than 40 have died from immobilisation complications since 2011. Seven percent exported out of South Africa died this way. But we are getting better at it. The first eight arrived in India alive and well.

What about disease or predation in their new home? An assessment of the disease risk by Adrian Tordiffe, associate professor at the University of Pretoria, is reassuring. The chance of them either transmitting or contracting any communicable diseases, he said, was judged to be low. Non-disease risks, such as starvation or conflict with local predators such as leopards or striped hyenas, were also minimal.

But there is a problem: Kuno is unfenced. “We’re used to operating in South Africa with fenced reserves where you have quite a lot more control,” he said in an interview with Our Burning Planet. “In India, you have got a human population of 1.3 billion and no fences.

Image
Cheetah competition in India. (Image: Supplied)

“All the cheetahs released in India will be collared and satellite-monitored. In South Africa, if a cheetah decided to wander 100km beyond a park we’d use a helicopter to bring it back. But in Kuno they just have 4x4s.”

This means serial wanderers will have to be chased, drugged and returned. Cheetahs are known to be susceptible to capture stress and often die because of it. Serial escapees will be sent to Mukundra Hill Tiger Reserve, which is fenced. Despite its name, it’s free of tigers, but does have leopards, wolves and striped hyenas. It could see the first encounter between an African cheetah and a wolf.

Kuno has one of the highest leopard densities in the world. But hopefully, the cheetahs are predator-savvy. They come from Phinda in KwaZulu-Natal, where they have been exposed to lions, leopards and hyenas.

“Because they’re going into areas where there’s quite a high leopard density,” said Tordiffe, “we wanted animals that are really quite wild.

“They’re not naïve of those carnivores and they can avoid them, they can defend themselves against them, they’re really aware of what they are and the risks that they pose to them.”

But there are risks. In South Africa, leopards are responsible for 9% and lions 30% of relocated cheetah mortalities.

If all goes according to plan, the 20 cheetahs will stay in a fenced area at Kuno for a month or so before being released into the park. When the gates are opened, every cheetah is on its own.

The risks will not be just predators. Kuno is surrounded by farmers with cattle, sheep, goats, chickens and dogs. The young of cattle, sheep and goats could prove tasty, while dogs may be a vector for distemper and rabies. Though farmers are well compensated for loss to tigers and the same would apply for cheetahs, there is a bushmeat problem.

Image

According to census research, Kuno has people who eat meat once a week or once a month on average. There is also a significant percentage that eats meat every day. Bushmeat snaring is prevalent in the region. People in the area were also found to own homemade guns, bows and arrows and catapults.

The facilitator

Vincent van der Merwe runs Cheetah Metapopulation and is both highly experienced in relocations and a consultant to the relocations from Namibia and South Africa. His job is to make sure they get there alive and well. The Namibian cheetahs arrived intact and he’s enthusiastic about the whole relocation plan.

“India has a completely different population methodology with a completely different mindset — they have a coexistence approach. There’s no fencing. There’s no retaliatory killings. Indians around Kuno belong to a completely different religious outlook.

“South Africa has a surplus of cheetahs and we would have to euthanise or contracept them, neither of which is optimal. So relocating is a good idea.

“There are definitely a lot of ambitious people involved enjoying the media attention,” he added, “but it’s also been a dream for many high-profile Indian conservationists. It’s gonna be one hell of an uphill battle, there are going to be massive losses initially.

“But, you know, we’ll learn. Indian parks have huge, unproductive buffer zones bringing in no revenue. They could hire them out as private game reserves.”

He says the successful establishment of cheetahs in the proposed introduction sites in India will need to be managed until at least 1,000 cheetahs are in place.

“This will require long-term commitment by South African and Namibian authorities to provide unrelated cheetahs for relocation to India. We hope that within 10 years we could have some form of population growth in India, but certainly, within the first 10 years of this project, there is going to be a lot of heartache and pain.”

The Indian conservationists

Once released, though, the big cats will almost certainly walk out of the unfenced park, “and then they’ll have a hell of a problem,” says Ullas Karanth, emeritus director for the non-profit Centre for Wildlife Studies and a specialist in large carnivores. “The cheetahs will get trashed and killed very quickly because there’s nothing outside of Kuno — it’s villages, dogs and farms.”

“There’s not any chance for free-ranging cheetah populations now,” adds Arjun Gopalaswamy, an independent conservation scientist who has conducted research on big cats in Africa and India. Cheetahs in India “perished for a reason”— human pressure, which has only got worse in the 70 years since the species disappeared. “So the first question is, why is this attempt even being made?”

Wildlife biologist and conservation scientist Dr Ravi Chellam of the Metastring Foundation says the cheetah project is poorly conceived and grossly expensive.

“The cheetahs will require intensive hands-on management over decades,” he said. “The government has still not implemented the 2013 court order to translocate Asiatic lions, of which there are only around 700 in the world, from Gir, Gujarat, to Kuno but they’re quick to implement a 2020 order to bring in cheetahs from Africa, which number around 7,000 in the world. Which is more endangered?

Image
An Indian public awareness poster. (Image: Supplied)

“This project is being rushed through to meet some goals other than conservation. The conservation goals are unrealistic and even unfeasible. Unfortunately, this will be a very costly mistake. It will be one of the most expensive conservation projects India has undertaken.

“We do not have habitats of the size cheetahs require. Without suitable high-quality habitats, this project is unlikely to succeed.”

Prerna Singh Bindra, a wildlife conservationist and former member of the National Wildlife Board, also said she wouldn’t classify the cheetah translocation project as a conservation project.

“Such projects, though sexy, are a distraction to our core objective of conserving wildlife and ecosystems. The cheetah is one of the widest-ranging of big cats and is known to travel across areas in excess of 1,000 km2 in a year. Historically, India has lost about 90% to 95% of its grasslands, 31% in a decade between 2005 and 2015. So where will the cheetah roam if it were ever returned to the wild?”

As the South African Department of Forestry, Fisheries and Environment ponders over the memorandum of understanding it is about to sign, it’s hoped they’ll have looked at all sides of the question. DM/OBP


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Richprins
Committee Member
Posts: 76096
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 3:52 pm
Location: NELSPRUIT
Contact:

Re: Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Post by Richprins »

What to do? -O- 0:


Please check Needs Attention pre-booking: https://africawild-forum.com/viewtopic.php?f=322&t=596
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67571
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Post by Lisbeth »

-O-


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67571
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Post by Lisbeth »

Cheetahs cleared for take-off after South Africa-India ‘extinction reversal’ agreement

Image
Some of the last cheetahs in India were shot in 1947, though wildlife historian and scholar Divyabhanusinh reports credible sightings of isolated cheetahs in remote areas into the 1960s and possibly 1975. (Photo: Constant Hoogstad)

By Tony Carnie | 27 Jan 2023

The ambitious conservation project offers the hope of creating vital new living space for wild cheetah populations but it has drawn both praise and criticism from experts and conservation groups.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________
A dozen cheetahs — all cooped up in small boma enclosures for the last six months — are finally set to embark on a 9,000km journey to a new home on another continent within the next two weeks.

This follows a series of delays in the signing of an official memorandum of understanding between the governments of South Africa and India to move up to 120 African cheetahs to Asia over the next decade.

The plan to re-introduce this charismatic hunting cat species to a continent where cheetahs have been extinct for roughly seven decades has drawn both acclaim and criticism from wildlife experts and conservation groups.

Those in favour believe the conservation project offers the hope of creating vital new living space for wild cheetah populations after a precipitous decline in the species due to relentless human pressure.

However, critics have questioned whether it is still feasible to re-establish the species in Asia while others have characterised the translocation as a “vanity” project that harks back to the days when wealthy Indian princes trained cheetahs to hunt down antelopes or kept them as pets.

Image
Cheetahs have vanished from 90% of their historical range in Africa and almost entirely the Middle East/Asia. The grey shading shows their historical range, and the red shading shows the range where cheetah are believed to be resident. (Source: PNAS / Durant et al 2016)
Nevertheless, there are now just 6,500 mature adults left in shrinking wild habitats globally. Cheetahs have vanished from 90% of their historical range in Africa and entirely from Asia — with fewer than 30 Asiatic cheetahs left in the world (all in Iran).

India has been trying to source Asiatic specimens since the mid-1950s. but the Iranian population is now too small to be fragmented for relocation to other nations.

Earlier this week, South Africa’s national environment department confirmed that, following months of delays, a Memorandum of Understanding had been signed with India.

Under this agreement, an initial batch of 12 cheetahs is scheduled to fly from South Africa to India in mid-February, joining eight cheetahs introduced from Namibia in September 2022.

“Restoring cheetah populations is considered to be a priority for India and will have vital and far-reaching conservation consequences, which would aim to achieve a number of ecological objectives, including re-establishing the function role of cheetah within their historical range in India and improving and enhancing the livelihood options and economies of the local communities,” the department said in a statement on January 26.

It also confirmed plans to translocate up to a dozen cheetahs annually for the next 10 years at the request of the Indian government.

The project is being coordinated by South Africa’s Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE) in collaboration with the South African National Biodiversity Institute (Sanbi), South African National Parks (SANParks), the Cheetah Range Expansion Project, and the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) and the Wildlife Institute of India (WII).

Other partners assisting with the project include Dr Adrian Tordiffe of the University of Pretoria’s Faculty of Veterinary Science; the andBeyond Phinda Private Game Reserve and Rooiberg Veterinary Services.

The 12 donated cheetahs have been sourced from andBeyond Phinda Private Game Reserve, Tswalu Kalahari Reserve, Mapesu Game Reserve and the Waterberg Biosphere.

Though visually identical, the southern African cheetah (Acinonyx jubatus jubatus) is slightly different from the Asiatic cheetah subspecies (Acinonyx jubatus venaticus), having been separated genetically for several thousand years.

Vincent van der Merwe, head of the South African Cheetah Metapopulation Project, has been spearheading a local project to boost wild cheetah numbers by shifting animals around on a regular basis, mainly among smaller private wildlife reserves.

Image
Vincent van der Merwe (right) and wildlife vet Dr Brendan Tindall oversee the translocation of another two cheetahs from a South African reserve. (Photo: Cynthia Stroo)

The project has recorded remarkable success, more than doubling this metapopulation from 217 to 504 cheetahs in less than a decade. These animals are now spread across 69 reserves in four countries.

Van der Merwe expressed relief yesterday that the memorandum had now been signed, but also voiced frustration that the 12 animals had steadily lost fitness and health over the last six months because they had been confined in quarantine bomas while a final decision was made about their future.

“Obviously we are very relieved that the cheetahs are now ready to go, but their fitness and condition has been compromised by six months of boma quarantine.”

So far, all eight Namibian cheetahs moved to Kuno National Park in India last year have survived and started to hunt down Indian antelope in small enclosures within the park. But the real test will come in a few months when they have to find free-ranging prey and also contend with leopards, wolves and bears in the larger, unfenced 75,000-hectare park.

Further criticism has come from Indian wildlife biologist and conservation scientist Dr Ravi Chellam who argues that the cheetah translocation project is “poorly conceived and grossly expensive”.

He noted that the Kuno reserve was originally earmarked to expand the range of Asiatic lions. Chellan says there are only around 700 of these lions left in the world, and their translocation should take priority over cheetahs from Africa — DM/OBP


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67571
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Post by Lisbeth »

Cheetahs cleared for take-off after South Africa-India ‘extinction reversal’ agreement

Image
Some of the last cheetahs in India were shot in 1947, though wildlife historian and scholar Divyabhanusinh reports credible sightings of isolated cheetahs in remote areas into the 1960s and possibly 1975. (Photo: Constant Hoogstad)

By Tony Carnie | 27 Jan 2023

The ambitious conservation project offers the hope of creating vital new living space for wild cheetah populations but it has drawn both praise and criticism from experts and conservation groups.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________
A dozen cheetahs — all cooped up in small boma enclosures for the last six months — are finally set to embark on a 9,000km journey to a new home on another continent within the next two weeks.

This follows a series of delays in the signing of an official memorandum of understanding between the governments of South Africa and India to move up to 120 African cheetahs to Asia over the next decade.

The plan to re-introduce this charismatic hunting cat species to a continent where cheetahs have been extinct for roughly seven decades has drawn both acclaim and criticism from wildlife experts and conservation groups.

Those in favour believe the conservation project offers the hope of creating vital new living space for wild cheetah populations after a precipitous decline in the species due to relentless human pressure.

However, critics have questioned whether it is still feasible to re-establish the species in Asia while others have characterised the translocation as a “vanity” project that harks back to the days when wealthy Indian princes trained cheetahs to hunt down antelopes or kept them as pets.

Image
Cheetahs have vanished from 90% of their historical range in Africa and almost entirely the Middle East/Asia. The grey shading shows their historical range, and the red shading shows the range where cheetah are believed to be resident. (Source: PNAS / Durant et al 2016)
Nevertheless, there are now just 6,500 mature adults left in shrinking wild habitats globally. Cheetahs have vanished from 90% of their historical range in Africa and entirely from Asia — with fewer than 30 Asiatic cheetahs left in the world (all in Iran).

India has been trying to source Asiatic specimens since the mid-1950s. but the Iranian population is now too small to be fragmented for relocation to other nations.

Earlier this week, South Africa’s national environment department confirmed that, following months of delays, a Memorandum of Understanding had been signed with India.

Under this agreement, an initial batch of 12 cheetahs is scheduled to fly from South Africa to India in mid-February, joining eight cheetahs introduced from Namibia in September 2022.

“Restoring cheetah populations is considered to be a priority for India and will have vital and far-reaching conservation consequences, which would aim to achieve a number of ecological objectives, including re-establishing the function role of cheetah within their historical range in India and improving and enhancing the livelihood options and economies of the local communities,” the department said in a statement on January 26.

It also confirmed plans to translocate up to a dozen cheetahs annually for the next 10 years at the request of the Indian government.

The project is being coordinated by South Africa’s Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE) in collaboration with the South African National Biodiversity Institute (Sanbi), South African National Parks (SANParks), the Cheetah Range Expansion Project, and the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) and the Wildlife Institute of India (WII).

Other partners assisting with the project include Dr Adrian Tordiffe of the University of Pretoria’s Faculty of Veterinary Science; the andBeyond Phinda Private Game Reserve and Rooiberg Veterinary Services.

The 12 donated cheetahs have been sourced from andBeyond Phinda Private Game Reserve, Tswalu Kalahari Reserve, Mapesu Game Reserve and the Waterberg Biosphere.

Though visually identical, the southern African cheetah (Acinonyx jubatus jubatus) is slightly different from the Asiatic cheetah subspecies (Acinonyx jubatus venaticus), having been separated genetically for several thousand years.

Vincent van der Merwe, head of the South African Cheetah Metapopulation Project, has been spearheading a local project to boost wild cheetah numbers by shifting animals around on a regular basis, mainly among smaller private wildlife reserves.

Image
Vincent van der Merwe (right) and wildlife vet Dr Brendan Tindall oversee the translocation of another two cheetahs from a South African reserve. (Photo: Cynthia Stroo)

The project has recorded remarkable success, more than doubling this metapopulation from 217 to 504 cheetahs in less than a decade. These animals are now spread across 69 reserves in four countries.

Van der Merwe expressed relief yesterday that the memorandum had now been signed, but also voiced frustration that the 12 animals had steadily lost fitness and health over the last six months because they had been confined in quarantine bomas while a final decision was made about their future.

“Obviously we are very relieved that the cheetahs are now ready to go, but their fitness and condition has been compromised by six months of boma quarantine.”

So far, all eight Namibian cheetahs moved to Kuno National Park in India last year have survived and started to hunt down Indian antelope in small enclosures within the park. But the real test will come in a few months when they have to find free-ranging prey and also contend with leopards, wolves and bears in the larger, unfenced 75,000-hectare park.

Further criticism has come from Indian wildlife biologist and conservation scientist Dr Ravi Chellam who argues that the cheetah translocation project is “poorly conceived and grossly expensive”.

He noted that the Kuno reserve was originally earmarked to expand the range of Asiatic lions. Chellan says there are only around 700 of these lions left in the world, and their translocation should take priority over cheetahs from Africa — DM/OBP


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67571
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Post by Lisbeth »

Why has it taken so long to sign the memorandum :-? Political issues? I trust the Indians even less than the SAs in that sector O**


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67571
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Post by Lisbeth »

Running for their lives – last-minute bid to stop cheetah export to India

Image
Twelve formerly wild cheetahs are destined for India today. (Photo: Don Pinnock)

By Don Pinnock | 16 Feb 2023

Twelve formerly wild cheetahs, which have been in holding pens for over seven months, are scheduled to be crated and flown to India on Friday, 17 February. But a conservation group is trying to stop this from happening, declaring it a violation of regulations.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The cheetahs are destined for Kuno National Park in Madhya Pradesh, central India, to join eight others imported from Namibia in September 2022. The cats have been penned since July last year, awaiting the go-ahead. The deal has now been signed off by the South African Department of Environmental Affairs.

Image
The entrance gate of Kuno National Parkin Madhya Pradesh, central India. (Photo: Supplied)

From the beginning, there has been controversy about the project. Kuno National Park is unfenced and surrounded by farmers with cattle, sheep, goats, chickens and dogs. The young of the first three could prove tasty, the last may be a vector for distemper and rabies. The park also contains leopards, wolves and striped hyenas.

Lawyers acting for the EMS Foundation have petitioned Environment Minister Barbara Creecy to stop the export until the risks to the animals’ survival are properly established and public comment has been obtained. They have deemed the export effectively illegal.

The export is said to be the first of a relocation of 120 wild cheetahs to India over a period of 10 years.

EMS Foundation lawyers say the export is based on an outdated non-detriment finding (NDF) – such findings by the Scientific Authority are required to ensure export is not detrimental to the wild population.

They say the finding permitting the cheetah export was based on a 2020 NDF that is out of date, was not ratified and was only issued for public comment.

So the export is effectively based on a 2015 NDF “and does not appear to be robust” because that NDF recommended a zero export quota.

Read on Daily Maverick: Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Vulnerable

Cheetahs are vulnerable and decreasing in number, with an estimated 6,517 alive globally. Their populations are extremely fragmented and confined to around 9% of their historical range. Most are on unprotected lands and face multiple threats.

According to the letter to Creecy, an unacceptable number of cheetahs are likely to be lost through the stress of translocation, having to undergo a long quarantine, having to deal with unfamiliar predators and the fact that the reserves in India are unfenced, which will bring them into conflict with humans. There is also a disease risk.

“There appears to be little knowledge about feline viruses in India, or any information about the diseases which the cheetah may in turn introduce to India… cheetah are highly susceptible to feline infectious peritonitis virus and India has no baseline information regarding this virus.”

Image
Lawyers are petitioning for Environment Minister Barbara Creecy to stop the export. (Photo: Don Pinnock)

When the first eight cheetahs were relocated from Namibia, wildlife biologist and conservation scientist Dr Ravi Chellam of the Metastring Foundation called the project poorly conceived and grossly expensive.

“The cheetahs will require intensive hands-on management over decades,” he said.

“The government has still not implemented the 2013 court order to translocate Asiatic lions, of which there are only around 700 in the world, from Gir, Gujarat, to Kuno, but they’re quick to implement a 2020 order to bring in cheetahs from Africa, which number less than 7,000 in the world. Which is more endangered?

“This project is being rushed through to meet some goals other than conservation. The conservation goals are unrealistic and even unfeasible. Unfortunately, this will be a very costly mistake. It will be one of the most expensive conservation projects India has undertaken.

“We do not have habitats of the size cheetahs require. Without suitable high-quality habitats, this project is unlikely to succeed,” said Chellam.

‘Massive losses’

Vincent van der Merwe, who runs the Cheetah Metapopulation Project and worked with the relocation of the cats, said, “It’s gonna be one hell of an uphill battle… there are going to be massive losses initially.”

He admitted that the successful establishment of cheetahs into the proposed introduction sites would need to be managed until at least 1,000 cheetahs are in place.

Read more on Daily Maverick: Translocation of SA cheetahs to India — ‘there is going to be a lot of heartache and pain’

“This will require long-term commitment by South African and Namibian authorities to provide unrelated cheetahs for relocation to India. Certainly, within the first 10 years of this project, there’s going to be a lot of heartache and pain.”

But he said South Africa has a surplus of cheetahs that would have to be euthanised or stopped from breeding, neither of which was optimal. So relocation was a good idea.

Image
Cheetah numbers are decreasing, with an estimate of just over 6,500 alive globally. (Photo: Don Pinnock)

Prerna Singh Bindra, wildlife conservationist and former member of the Indian National Wildlife Board, was sceptical, saying she wouldn’t classify the project as conservation.

“Such projects, though sexy, are a distraction to our core objective of conserving wildlife and ecosystems. The cheetah is one of the widest-ranging of big cats and known to travel across areas in excess of 1,000km2 in a year.

“Historically, India has lost about 90% to 95% of its grasslands; 31% in a decade between 2005 and 2015. So where will the cheetah roam if it were ever returned to the wild?”

Three of the 12 cheetahs due to be sent to India have been kept in quarantine in Phinda, KwaZulu-Natal, since 15 July 2022, while nine have been quarantined in Rooiberg, Limpopo.

Ten quarantine enclosures have been created for the South African cheetahs at Kuno, where the eight Namibian felines were placed last year.

If the relocation goes ahead – and it probably will – a military C17 aircraft from the Hindon air base in Uttar Pradesh fetch the cheetahs from South Africa. A team of South African and Indian veterinarians and wildlife experts will accompany them.

The five female and seven male cheetahs will then be transferred from the Gwalior air base where they’ll land on Saturday morning before being transported to Kuno in an Mi-17 helicopter.

Read on Daily Maverick: Cheetahs cleared for take-off after South Africa-India ‘extinction reversal’ agreement

The Memorandum of Understanding signed between India and South Africa in January this year approves translocations of 10 to 12 cheetahs annually “until a sustainable cheetah population is established in India”.

In addition, four to eight cheetahs will be imported from Namibia each year for the next five years.

If all goes according to plan, the 20 cheetahs will stay in a fenced area at Kuno before being released into the park.

After that, every cheetah will have to figure out how to survive in unknown, untested territory. DM/OBP


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
User avatar
Lisbeth
Site Admin
Posts: 67571
Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
Country: Switzerland
Location: Lugano
Contact:

Re: Twelve Southern African speed cats travel 9,000km to bring extinct cheetahs back to life in India

Post by Lisbeth »

Another of the cheetahs transferred to India from Africa dies

Image
© AP /Keystone

ATS - 24.04.2023 09:56

A cheetah from the group of twelve cheetahs that arrived in India from South Africa last February died in the Kuno Game Reserve in the Indian state of Madhya Pradesh. The managers of the park, where another specimen died earlier this month, say they have not yet identified the cause of the death of this six-year-old feline.

India reintroduced cheetahs into its territory last summer with an operation that received great media coverage: the first eight cats that arrived from Namibia were joined by another twelve in February, transferred from South Africa.

One of the females of the Namibian group gave birth to four cubs on March 29, the first born in the family of these great big cats, declared extinct in India in 1947.

The country is paying particular attention to the adaptation of "foreign" cheetahs to their new habitat.


"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
Post Reply

Return to “Lions and Other Endangered Animals Management and Poaching”