Page 12 of 73

Re: Rhino Poaching 2014

Posted: Thu Feb 06, 2014 11:22 am
by Duke
Hi wynand 0/*

I quote Tim Condon
The 2014 Dilemma !!
How & who to tackle the criminal, poacher colluding elements in the 600 strong Field Staff Rangers - repeatedly reported by top APU sources to be as high as 25-40% ?? They are protected by an arrogant Trade Union, censorship & propaganda by ANC cadres in the top corrupt echelons of SA Government & SANParks management - indeed a dangerous time bomb for the rhino !!

The question is who will be bold enough to tackle this untenable situation & would it accomplish anything useful ?? Should sleeping dogs be left to just hopefully die ?? That of course goes against any conservationists grain !! TC ~~

NB :: Shock January record poaching - Why ?? There much more to the poaching than just cross-border Mozambicans - it time to look and act inwards !! Repeated reports from top observers & APU sources of elements of KNP Field staff corruption & collusion (some say 20% to 30%), protected by their Trade Union & ANC propaganda cadres ?? - There’s never smoke without a fire ?? The situation is disgraceful & an insult to the genuine dedicated APU’s & loyal staff.
What is your view on this?

Thanks

Re: Rhino Poaching 2013

Posted: Thu Feb 06, 2014 11:30 am
by wynand
H. erectus wrote:Oh my word,..what will happen to all this money???

Almost all involved in this poaching matter are on
some sort of payroll compensation!! Most equipment
has been donated,... :-? :shock: -O- 0=
The projects I'm involved with are funded chiefly by land-owners and private donors. Many of the role players and organisers are voluntary and won't expect compensation of any kind. We do, however, feel a desperate need for more equipment, uniforms, rations, training and staff.

There are large reserves, not in private hands, where rhino migrate freely to and from Kruger. Lack of radios, vehicles and trained staff severly hamper the ability of present employees to prevent poaching.

I'm here to tell you that the war is fought on a massive front. Such that the millions already donated, though much appreciated, falls short of buying the protection that we need. Oh, I can just sense the suspicions that my words arouse in this forum. My and my colleague's involvement has been funded out of our own pockets and by businesses and individuls that are part of the project. Our time that we spend anti-poaching is taken off from work. We are closely associated with organisations that receive external funding and equipment from Govt., and the rhino campaigns that we see. The radios, optical equipment, uniforms, ration packs, rucksacks, arms & ammo, gps's, vehicles etc. are always in short supply. I was working with a unit in hot pursuit of armed poachers recently and they did not have a radio (no funds to repair their existing sets). Hand signals and messengers were our only means of comms. I was surprised that these guys have not had their spirit broken by the lack of support they face. Yet, they are entrusted with protecting a significant part of, what I call, the "national rhino herd" (not those animals that are privately owned, but those that roam Kruger, Ezemvelo and adjacent land. Those that belong to "all of us" yet to none of us specifically).

Indeed, we have to be wary of the misapplication of funds, but rather than simply voicing our distrust, get involved! If you are far from the front, join a campaign and make your voice heard. Its easy to criticise from the sidelines. Get unto the field and play for your side!

Re: Rhino Poaching 2014

Posted: Thu Feb 06, 2014 12:38 pm
by wynand
Hiya, Duke

I must say that at the level I operate, "arrogant Trade Union, censorship & propaganda by ANC cadres in the top corrupt echelons of SA Government & SANParks management" is not an indictment that springs readily to mind.

I'm not sure at all where the ANC cadres, Trade Unions and censorship come into play. Perhaps Tim is exposed to stuff that I have been spared.

I can, however, tell you that insiders and moles are being caught out. It is plain to me that they have been corrupted by the lure of money offered by the poaching syndicates. I see no involvement here by the parties mentioned by Tim.

My view is that it is much simpler than that:
Security worker, game viewer driver, lodge chef, even members of the ill defined "ranger corps", perhaps my closest colleague and, for all you know, I too, am offered a few thousand for sending geotagged smart-phone images of a rhino. Or to divulge the planned movements of security teams. Or to feed misleading info to the APU's.
That is where our problems lie. Not a major conspiracy, but plain old graft and bribery, at the lowest level.

I have seen poaching figures decline dramaticaly in a particular area after staff, flagged by VSA/polygraph tests, have been transferred or retrenched. We are now all subjected to VSA or similar tests. From top management to patrolmen.

But don't let the few crooked members who get rooted out cast an ill light on the anti-poaching forces as a whole.

At the level of government, my gripe is not rampant corruption and conspiracy, but rather a lack of political will to attack the rhino problem at all levels. The war on the ground can never be "won". We are only buying time (and that is vitally important at this stage). The problem can only be curtailed once demand for rhino horn is reduced. Unfortunately, we seem to facing the opposite situation: Stemming the flow of rhino horn curtail supply. Demand, if anything, seems to be rising. The value of horn has escalated dramatically. More incentive for crime syndicates to spread the dough more generously, recruiting more poachers at a higher premium.

It does not help that folks in the villages have no ideological grounds by which to align their sympathies. After a recent killing of a known poacher, local residents protested in the streets and blocked access to a reserve. Poaching brings in money to poor villages. Cell phones, cars, double story houses. Again, the simple but effective lure of money and comfort.

Direct your anger at the buyers and end-users of rhino horn, at the crime syndicates who corrupt relatively innocent people (simple, poor men who become the fodder in this war). Motivate government to take a political stand and to engage with international crime prevention agencies. We need all nations to bear down on those that allow rhino horn to be sold on their streets.

Lasly, in my view, the allegation that there exists a "top corrupt echelon" in SANParks is misdirected and unfounded.

Re: Rhino Poaching 2014

Posted: Thu Feb 06, 2014 1:44 pm
by Duke
Thanks for the comprehensive reply wynand \O
But don't let the few crooked members who get rooted out cast an ill light on the anti-poaching forces as a whole.
I am not making any judgements on the antipoaching forces and I think many of them put their lives at risk daily and for that I applaud them and support them
At the level of government, my gripe is not rampant corruption and conspiracy, but rather a lack of political will to attack the rhino problem at all levels. The war on the ground can never be "won". We are only buying time (and that is vitally important at this stage). The problem can only be curtailed once demand for rhino horn is reduced. Unfortunately, we seem to facing the opposite situation: Stemming the flow of rhino horn curtail supply. Demand, if anything, seems to be rising. The value of horn has escalated dramatically. More incentive for crime syndicates to spread the dough more generously, recruiting more poachers at a higher premium.
I also sense a lack of political will. Our borders are breached daily by trained armed insurgents and IMO we are not commiting sufficient resorces to stop the slaughtering of our rhinos.

Are we really going to reduce the demand for rhino horn.
Lasly, in my view, the allegation that there exists a "top corrupt echelon" in SANParks is misdirected and unfounded.
I do not have any information to the contary and therefore was asking for your view. I think we should get information from as many sources as we can. What did come as a shock to me though was that SANParks were still selling rhinos up tp September 2013 and possibly still are. We don't know to who and what due diligence is carried out.

I also know that in answer to a parliamentary question on the sale of rhinos the answer given by the DEA did not tie up with figures documented by CITES on the sale of rhinos to China, Vietnam and Thailand.

Re: Rhino Poaching 2013

Posted: Thu Feb 06, 2014 6:12 pm
by Richprins
wynand wrote: Oh, I can just sense the suspicions that my words arouse in this forum.

Indeed, we have to be wary of the misapplication of funds, but rather than simply voicing our distrust, get involved! If you are far from the front, join a campaign and make your voice heard. Its easy to criticise from the sidelines. Get unto the field and play for your side!
No suspicions, wynand! We are a relaxed bunch! :-0

H. erectus wasn't talking about you, I don't think, and has just completed a R90 000-odd AW rhino project he initiated, for example! X#X

In fact, your words are crystal clear and it is stupendous to hear someone willing to call a spade a spade! ^Q^ ^Q^ ^Q^


Thank you very much indeed!

I would add that SA Dept of International Affairs/Customs and Excise employees play a role too, imo, as one often reads of horn/ivory being picked up abroad after being cleared by them...

Re: Rhino Poaching 2014

Posted: Thu Feb 06, 2014 7:29 pm
by H. erectus
Hello Wynand,...

I read your well wish and concern,...

and appreciate your comment,..obviously a die hard you are,
Which gets all my respect,...probably one of 90% that do very
good work out there!!

Fact is there are many of your ilk out there doing flippin' hard
graft out there!!! The fact that rhino poaching hits an area far
greater than .gov controlled land I very well understand!!!

Now in the greater sense of imagination, if rhino were allowed
to free roam boundaries then surely the grant(232million) were
to free roam as well!!!

Now I ask Wynand, are you getting a cut from this grant or maybe
just hoping that some over spill comes your way???, because rhino's
are free roaming???

Hey Wynand your not my enemy, will never be geez boet!!!!

Re: Rhino Poaching 2014

Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2014 10:26 am
by wynand
No worries, mate. I was taking a poke at Okie.

Re: Free roaming and expecting a cut:
(I'm afraid I have to provide some background first)

My little part in this is independently funded by aviation businesses, aviation enthusiasts and ourselves. We provide free air support to all anti-poaching forces in the Sabisand, Manyeleti, Timbavati, Klaserie, Balule and a number of smaller reserves. We're quite busy.

One of many teams we operate with. In this case, a team from Protrack. Image

Rhino and other charismatic megafauna move freely between Kruger and these reserves and, by agreement, the reserves must take care of these animals while they're in their area of responsibility. The individual property owners within these reserves are now faced with a large security bill. I would say much larger than they anticipated when they invested in their properties. They also didn't know they'd be in for a counter-insugency war, with armed uniformed men roaming their private land and aircraft circling overhead. All this for protecting a national asset, not their own animals. The wardens, instead of devoting their time and expertise to veld management and important stuff that wardens are expected to do, spend much of their time being area commanders of private armies.

In-house rangers and student rangers in the Umbabat: Image

In spite of this, an inordinate number of rhinos are being poached on these lands. A security analyst recently pointed out that it is puzzling that this area, which has a much higher staff-on-the-ground density than Kruger, is suffering a higher concentration of rhino mortality. That just smacks of corruption doesn't it? Well, there is a little truth in such suspicions because, as I pointed out, some crooked staff have been caught out and one can expect there will always be more. The larger, and glaringly obvious reason is that these lands are the Western Front Line of Kruger. There is a population of a million people living in peri-urban conditions along the convoluted western boundaries of these reserves, with multiple access gates and 100's of km of boundary to patrol. A band of poachers would much rather do their work close to the boundary they breached, to have a good chance of escaping. Of course they're not going to walk all the way through the Timbavati, say, to Kruger if their quarry can be seen from the fence (as they all too often are). With all the convolutions the western boundary lines total more than 500km. The private reserves I mentioned are taking care of about 200km of a westward-displaced border, thereby forming a buffer between Kruger and the densely populated part of the Lowveld.

Google Earth Image with the western boundary of Sabisand and Manyeleti drawn in yellow. Image


Now, on the Eastern boundary Kruger is facing the mammoth task of trying to maintain the integrity of a 350km+ (by my quick estimate) boundary with Mozambique and with a lower staff density on the ground. Many, if not most incursions into Kruger itself are presently from there and the poacher bands roam deep into our National Park.

Then there's KZN, with multiple parks, scattered over a large area and each of them surrounded by "hostile" borders. I don't have figures, but during a briefing in Hluhluwe, I was astounded by the scale of their border problem. Kudos to that province for opening its coffers to the funding of anti-poaching.

With this rough sketch of the battleground and deployments above, I can get back to "Expecting a Cut".

No, I and my small operation do not expect a cut. We source our own donations from the aviation community. However, I see a great need for more support to the reserves we serve.
At this point I must acknowledge some of the support that is already in place.
SANParks is funding a large project whereby Environmental Monitors (EM's)are recruited, trained and deployed in the reserves and communities adjoining Kruger and other National Parks. Most are youngsters who deal with veld monitoring, erosion control and the like, but many are trained and eventually armed for anti-poaching duty as well.

A newly qualified team of EM's on their deployment day.Image

A welcome trickle of funds and equipment from the various funding drives is finding its way to the reserves I serve. When I say "trickle" I'm talking of an occasional injection in the order of R100 000. A lot of money, but relatively little compared to the overall flow of "rhino funds" and relatively little compared to what the land owners are forking out.

R100k worth of equipment to member reserves of Game Reserves United from Jacaranda FM via StopRhinoPoaching.com. Image

Bottom line, I'm told, is that I have put faith in the national prioritization strategy for the appropriate allocation of the funds we are talking about here.

Re: Rhino Poaching 2014

Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2014 10:42 am
by Flutterby
Wynand, thank you and all those you work with for doing such a great and worthwhile job!! ^Q^ ^Q^

Re: Rhino Poaching 2014

Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2014 10:43 am
by Duke
Thanks for that informative background wynand \O

Sterkte Mate \O

Re: Rhino Poaching 2014

Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2014 11:00 am
by mouseinthehouse
wynand;

I just want to say a huge thank you for sharing this very insightful information about the situation in an open and frank manner. I have learned more in the last five minutes reading your posts than on various forums over the last several months.

The highest respect to you and your fellow colleagues working to protect rhino. It is a massive personal contribution from each person and cannot be underestimated. Without people like you and the teams you work with the situation would be much worse. O0 O0 O0