Rhino Poaching: Arrests, Prosecutions & Sentencing

[Lisbeth]

Has he never been in jail yet, considered all the other crimes included poaching, committed years ago?

[Richprins]

Here his story begins in 2011 already...


https://africawild-forum.com/viewtopic. ... 61&p=60718

[Richprins]

Joseph “Big Joe” Nyalunga’s case transferred to the Nelspruit Regional Court
They were released on R1 000 bail three weeks ago and are due back in court on September 8 .
2 days ago
Enver Wessels

WHITE RIVER – The White River Magistrate’s Court transferred the kidnapping and murder case against Joseph Nyalunga (54) and his co-accused, Elvis Mulimi (50), to the Nelspruit Regional Court today.

https://lowvelder.co.za/700001/joseph-b ... nal-court/

[Richprins]

Light sentences for poachers take toll on anti-poaching rangers


Considering the amount of effort and funds that go into arresting a suspected poacher, and seeing court proceedings through, cases such as this take a significant toll on the people involved in seeking justice.
1 day ago


The sentence of an alleged rhino poacher recently charged with trespassing and being in possession of a dangerous weapon was a mere slap on the wrist, and he currently walks free.

The man was sentenced to a R10,000 fine or two years’ imprisonment, suspended for five years, in the Bushbuckridge district.

Considering the amount of effort and funds that go into arresting a suspected poacher, and seeing court proceedings through, cases such as this take a significant toll on the people involved in seeking justice.

Not only is this demoralising for rangers involved in intense anti-poaching units, but it also wastes precious resources used to nab poachers.

This according to Stop Rhino Poaching founder Elise Serfontein, who said incidents such as this prove why it is so critical to reopen the Skukuza Regional Court, which has a good conviction rate.

“Various technologies, vehicles, ranger training, ranger equipment and force multipliers like tracking dogs all form part of the staggering financial investment by donors and the State to build and maintain strategic on the ground capabilities that protect rhinos from poachers,” she explained.

Air support in the form of helicopters is sometimes needed leading up to an arrest.

When an arrest is made, expenses relating to the investigation and court proceedings, which can take months or years to complete, are also incurred.

Lawyers hired by poachers often attack every possible technicality they can, and delay cases for as long as possible, Serfontein said.

A poacher could be arrested on a day, and “bump into them at the shops in a few days’ time”, a ranger who wished to remain anonymous told The Citizen.

“It is very demoralising that we cannot rely on the justice system. We work hard, we risk our lives and we do our jobs with pride. We are trying to save the rhino but the courts are failing us.

“The don’t understand and they don’t care and nor does our government,” the ranger explained.

Serfontein said there was a staggering amount of effort involved getting poachers to court.

She explained that if the investigating officer and the State prosecutor are both “determined and focused, they make a formidable team with very good sentences.”

“The magistrate can only apply the law, but if the argument is detailed and convincing at least they can go for maximum sentencing.

“So in some courts, with poor sentences, you have to wonder how much effort went in.”

Other elements such as delay tactics by lawyers hired by poachers add to the stress involved in convicting a poacher and ensuring they are kept as far away from nature as possible.

But even when the money runs out and rhino poaching syndicates cease to pay, and the case is handed over to legal aid, more delays are experienced.

Anti-poaching rangers and organisations involved work on empty as they await sentences, and end up being disappointed and deflated when underwhelming convictions are handed out.

These are the same people who must continue protecting South Africa’s wildlife, regardless of convictions. This monumental task is not for the faint-hearted and is challenging enough on a good day.

“It’s not that it’s happened often, but there have been clear cut cases where poachers have walked, or have been given a slap on the wrist.”

https://lowvelder.co.za/lnn/1142109/lig ... g-rangers/

[Lisbeth]

I hope that the case will not be delayed for the umpteenth time I wonder why the case has been moved "next door"

[Lisbeth]

Yes, some of the sentences, especially a few years back, were laughable

Just think about Big Joe, who was arrested the first time in 2011 and is still free as a bird, even if he is also suspected of murder and quite a few other serious things

[RogerFraser]

Dr William Fowlds
7h

https://www.facebook.com/DrWilliamFowld ... 9196606020

CALL TO ACTION

TURN FACEBOOK RED, MONDAY 17 AUGUST.

Share/post the below image to stand shoulder to shoulder with us in support of our rhinos.

Convicted poaching gang ‘The Ndlovus’ are back in court Monday 17 August, to appeal their sentence. We can’t allow their sentence to be reduced, they we’re convicted on 55 counts of poaching, 55 rhino lives that were stolen. This sentence fits the crime and must be upheld.

Help us to show public support for this sentence by sharing the below image, with #55RhinoLives We can’t have a public protest due to Covid, so we are calling on you, our global rhino family, to help us get #JusticeforRhinos

3 rhinos for 3 poachers found guilty.
55 images for 55 rhino lives stolen.
1 message, we stand UNITED for our rhinos.
The sentence fits the crime and the sentence must be served.

#55RhinoLives #NoAppeal #NotInOurProvince #JusticeforRhinos #LetThePunishmentFitTheCrime #SeeRedForRhinos #RedForRhino

[Klipspringer]

The Lowvelder article is a questionable piece of reporting, where are the facts? What cases do they refer to?

This according to Stop Rhino Poaching founder Elise Serfontein, who said incidents such as this prove why it is so critical to reopen the Skukuza Regional Court, which has a good conviction rate.

I think the Skukuza Regional Court was saved in April. Correct me if I am wrong

According to the minister there is a trial there: https://www.environment.gov.za/mediarel ... gdecreases

The following are the high-profile cases currently enrolled:

7. State v R Landela & 1 other: Trial date: 11 September 2020 (Skukuza Regional Court)

(This is the regional KNP ranger arrested in 2016)

[Lisbeth]

First I thought that it was an old piece, but when I saw "Breaking News"...........

[Richprins]

Ja!

Maybe it was put up again by mistake?