Two get jail for illegal harvest of 134 Tonga cycads
Posted: Tue Feb 05, 2013 9:48 pm
Two get jail for illegal harvest of 134 Tonga cycads
February 5 2013 at 09:00am
By NOMFUNDO XOLO
.
Cycads that had survived three mass extinctions in the Earth’s history were now being wiped out through illegal harvesting.
This was the evidence of an Ezemvelo KZN Wildlife botanist that helped secure a three-year jail term for two cycad poachers on Monday. They were arrested in August in a police sting in northern KwaZulu-Natal.
Manguzi magistrate Brian Milner rejected the defence that S’phamandla Ngubane, 25, and Sibonelo Gcwabaza, 26 – both from the KwaNganase district – had been enticed by a police informer to harvest 134 Tonga cycads worth more than R100 000.
Cycads are protected worldwide by the Convention of International Trade in Endangered Species (Cites) and illegal possession can result in a 10-year jail sentence.
Defence lawyer Xolani Msimango argued that the two were young, vulnerable men who had been lured into a trap by a man called Bheki, to dig up plants for R500 each.
But Milner rejected this, citing contradictions in the versions given by Ngubane and Gcwabaza of how they had come to take cycads from the Tembe Elephant Park.
“It’s incredibly difficult for court to evaluate a case where an informer has been used. The court has to find something else to ensure that (the) informer is not falsely implicating the accused. That something can be found in the very poor quality of the evidence of Ngubane and Gcwabaza,” said Milner.
Regarding the seriousness of the offence, Milner referred to the evidence of Ezemvelo botanist, Paul Gordijn, who said that cycads were the most threatened plant species in the world – more endangered than the black and white rhino.
“They are the oldest living seed plant in the world.”
Of 38 South African species, two became extinct between 2003 and 2011, and seven species were “now down to less than 100 left in the wild”, he said.
Gordijn said cycads had become so vulnerable, that a local wild population could become extinct overnight.
State prosecutor, Waldo Smit, said the conviction sent out a strong message to illegal cycad harvesters.
Milner sentenced the two to three years in jail. – Roving Reporters
February 5 2013 at 09:00am
By NOMFUNDO XOLO
.
Cycads that had survived three mass extinctions in the Earth’s history were now being wiped out through illegal harvesting.
This was the evidence of an Ezemvelo KZN Wildlife botanist that helped secure a three-year jail term for two cycad poachers on Monday. They were arrested in August in a police sting in northern KwaZulu-Natal.
Manguzi magistrate Brian Milner rejected the defence that S’phamandla Ngubane, 25, and Sibonelo Gcwabaza, 26 – both from the KwaNganase district – had been enticed by a police informer to harvest 134 Tonga cycads worth more than R100 000.
Cycads are protected worldwide by the Convention of International Trade in Endangered Species (Cites) and illegal possession can result in a 10-year jail sentence.
Defence lawyer Xolani Msimango argued that the two were young, vulnerable men who had been lured into a trap by a man called Bheki, to dig up plants for R500 each.
But Milner rejected this, citing contradictions in the versions given by Ngubane and Gcwabaza of how they had come to take cycads from the Tembe Elephant Park.
“It’s incredibly difficult for court to evaluate a case where an informer has been used. The court has to find something else to ensure that (the) informer is not falsely implicating the accused. That something can be found in the very poor quality of the evidence of Ngubane and Gcwabaza,” said Milner.
Regarding the seriousness of the offence, Milner referred to the evidence of Ezemvelo botanist, Paul Gordijn, who said that cycads were the most threatened plant species in the world – more endangered than the black and white rhino.
“They are the oldest living seed plant in the world.”
Of 38 South African species, two became extinct between 2003 and 2011, and seven species were “now down to less than 100 left in the wild”, he said.
Gordijn said cycads had become so vulnerable, that a local wild population could become extinct overnight.
State prosecutor, Waldo Smit, said the conviction sent out a strong message to illegal cycad harvesters.
Milner sentenced the two to three years in jail. – Roving Reporters
