Re: Concerning new "Survey" from SanParks
Posted: Mon Jul 30, 2012 1:38 pm
Asking people their willingness to pay to for a sighting of a certain species might be an increasingly popular method for valuing biodiversity, but is prone to potential biases, showing responses to be expressions of what people would like to have happen rather than true valuations and hence the method’s
credibility suffers (Look at the comments here and elsewhere
)
Are there ethical concerns?
How can one place a price in ZAR on something as priceless as a wild animal? A valid question. Decisions are made constantly about developments that may affect biodiversity and so tradeoffs are being made, either explicitly or implicitly. For instance, if it is decided to build tourism infrastructure and so reduce the habitat availability for a suite of species, the value of what tourists pay (and the jobs created etc.) is seen as greater than the value of the potential loss of biodiversity. The trade-off between the monetary value of tourism products and the non-monetary value of the biodiversity has been made. Decisions involving trade-offs between biodiversity conservation and the value people gain from activities that utilise natural resources are difficult but a fact of life.

credibility suffers (Look at the comments here and elsewhere

Are there ethical concerns?
How can one place a price in ZAR on something as priceless as a wild animal? A valid question. Decisions are made constantly about developments that may affect biodiversity and so tradeoffs are being made, either explicitly or implicitly. For instance, if it is decided to build tourism infrastructure and so reduce the habitat availability for a suite of species, the value of what tourists pay (and the jobs created etc.) is seen as greater than the value of the potential loss of biodiversity. The trade-off between the monetary value of tourism products and the non-monetary value of the biodiversity has been made. Decisions involving trade-offs between biodiversity conservation and the value people gain from activities that utilise natural resources are difficult but a fact of life.


